How to Tell a Bad Idea
The same way you tell a good one. That’s it! End of class.
Obviously, you are an expert on the topic already, and you know instantly and categorically whether an idea is good or bad. You never even feel that tiny, insignificant twinge of jealousy when someone else comes up with something clever, and you never deliberately delay a paper with a scathing review before you publish yours or undermine that peer in front of your superiors. I know you don’t do these things because you are self-aware and spot logical fallacies from miles away. Cognitive biases never influence your reasoning; you always apply sound logic and are of strong moral character: no turpitude involved of any kind. I also know that just because you know a lot about one topic, you never assume over-competence in another.